Why email is the most important channel most artists ignore
Most independent artists are almost entirely dependent on social media for sales. Instagram goes down - sales stop. The algorithm changes - reach drops 60% overnight. A competitor outbids you on Meta - your ROAS tanks.
Email is different. You own the list. It doesn't cost money to reach. And it consistently generates 30–40% of total revenue for mature artist stores - often from people who bought once, two years ago, who you simply reminded existed.
This guide walks through building an email system from zero: which platform to use, which flows to build first, and how to write emails that actually get opened.
Step 1: Choose your email platform
For independent artists, the only two platforms worth considering are Klaviyo and Mailchimp.
Klaviyo - Our recommendation for anyone running a Shopify store. Deep Shopify integration means you can segment by purchase history, trigger flows based on browse behaviour, and track revenue per email. Starts free up to 250 contacts.
Mailchimp - Simpler, cheaper at scale, but weaker Shopify integration. Fine if you're just doing campaigns and not relying on advanced automation.
What to avoid: Substack, Beehiiv, and similar newsletter platforms are built for content, not ecommerce. They lack the purchase data integrations that make email genuinely profitable for stores.
Step 2: Build these three flows first
Flows are automated email sequences that trigger based on customer behaviour. They run 24/7 without you touching them.
These three account for 80% of email revenue for most stores:
1. Abandoned cart flow
Someone adds a product to their cart and doesn't buy. This flow brings them back.
Sequence:
- Email 1: 1 hour after abandonment - "Did you forget something?" Show the product, add urgency.
- Email 2: 24 hours after - Add social proof (reviews, how many people bought this week).
- Email 3: 48 hours after - Offer a small discount (10%) if you want to close the sale.
Expected results: 10–18% cart recovery rate. For a store doing £5k/month, this typically adds £500–900/month in revenue that would otherwise be lost.
2. Welcome series
Someone signs up to your list (via popup, social, etc.) but hasn't bought yet. This is your most important nurture sequence.
Sequence:
- Email 1: Immediate - Welcome, deliver the discount if you offered one, introduce your work.
- Email 2: Day 3 - Your story. Why do you make what you make? This is the most read email in the sequence.
- Email 3: Day 7 - Social proof. Show your best-selling products with real reviews.
- Email 4: Day 14 - Soft sell. Pick your two best products, present them simply.
Expected results: 20–35% of new subscribers convert within 30 days when this sequence is well-written.
3. Post-purchase flow
Someone just bought. They're at peak engagement with your brand. Use it.
Sequence:
- Email 1: Immediately after order - Thank you + what to expect (shipping timeline).
- Email 2: After delivery (3–7 days depending on fulfilment) - "How does it look?" Ask for a review, share how to photograph the print.
- Email 3: 30 days after purchase - "You might also like..." Show complementary products. This drives repeat purchase.
Expected results: 12–20% of customers make a second purchase within 90 days when this flow is in place vs. 4–6% without it.
Step 3: Run campaigns that people actually want to receive
Flows run automatically. Campaigns are emails you send manually to your list - new releases, limited drops, seasonal sales.
The mistake most artists make: sending campaigns that feel like ads. People unsubscribe from ads.
The artists with the highest open rates (40%+) send campaigns that feel like letters from a friend. Here's the framework we use:
Subject line: Specific and personal beats clever. "My new A2 prints just went live" outperforms "Something new is here ✨" every time.
Opening: One sentence, conversational, not about the sale. Start with a real thing that happened ("I finished this piece at 2am last Tuesday and I genuinely don't know where it came from.").
The ask: One product, one CTA. Not five products, not a general "shop now." Artists who send more focused campaigns see 2–3× higher click rates.
Frequency: Weekly is fine if you have something to say. Monthly if you don't. Daily is almost always wrong.
Step 4: Build your list
All of the above is worthless without people to send it to. Here's how to grow a high-quality list:
1. Popup on your store A simple "get 10% off your first order" popup converts 3–8% of store visitors. Install it on a 5-second delay, exclude existing customers.
2. Social bio link Your Instagram and TikTok bios should link to a dedicated landing page, not your homepage. The landing page should have one CTA: sign up for early access / behind-the-scenes updates.
3. Post-purchase capture At the checkout confirmation stage, invite buyers to join your VIP list for early access to new releases. Buyers are 4× more likely to open your emails than non-buyers.
4. Limited drop waitlists If you do limited edition releases, run a waitlist. People who sign up for a waitlist are your most engaged customers - they bought (or tried to buy) based on anticipation alone.
What good email metrics look like for artists
| Metric | Average (ecommerce) | Good (artist stores) | |--------|--------------------|--------------------| | Open rate | 22% | 35–45% | | Click rate | 2.5% | 4–8% | | Revenue per recipient | $0.08 | $0.25–0.60 | | Unsubscribe rate | 0.3% | under 0.2% |
If your open rate is below 20%, the problem is usually subject lines or list quality. If your click rate is below 2%, the problem is usually the email design or the offer.
The one thing that separates high-performing artist email lists
The artists with the most engaged lists share something specific: they write emails as themselves.
Not polished brand copy. Not "we're excited to announce." Their voice, their perspective, their actual thoughts about the work.
Your list signed up because they like you - your art, your aesthetic, your eye. Give them more of that, and every email becomes something they look forward to rather than something they tolerate.
Frequently asked questions
How many subscribers do I need before email is worth doing? Start immediately. Even with 100 subscribers, email outperforms social for sales. The value of email is that it compounds - a subscriber from three years ago is still worth reaching.
Should I buy an email list? Never. Purchased lists have terrible deliverability, damage your sender reputation, and generate zero real revenue. Every address on your list should have opted in explicitly.
How do I improve my open rates? Subject line testing is the highest-leverage change. Also: clean your list quarterly (remove subscribers who haven't opened in 6 months), send at the right time (Tuesday–Thursday mornings typically perform best), and authenticate your domain (SPF, DKIM, DMARC).
What's the best time to send? Tuesday and Thursday mornings (9–11am in your audience's timezone) are the safest default. But the only way to know what's right for your list is to test.
Want this done for you?
Get a free audit →